HomeMy WebLinkAbout2005-08-10 HHSCMINUTES OF THE
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION
City Clerk Conference Center
300 E.Superstition Blvd.,Apache Junction,AZ
August 10,2005 -3:00 P.M.
COMMISSIONERS PRESENT:
JOYCE PAYNE,CHAIRPERSON
SUE CLABUESCH,VICE CHAIRPERSON
KIMBERLY BROSSMAN
RUTHIE WEST
1.Call to Order/Roll Call.
STAFF PRESENT:
KATHLEEN CONNELLY,CITY CLERK
JAN MASON,DEPUTY CITY CLERK
Chairperson Payne called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m.Deputy City Clerk
Jan Mason called the roll and advised there was a quorum present.
2.Discussion on FY 2005-06 funding applications and procedure for
reviewing applications and 3.Status report on FY 2004-05 funding
recipients.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly briefed the commission on the item.She stated
they received seven applications this year.She had written on the board the
amount they are requesting this year in blue,and the amount they received
this past year in black if they were funded.Community Alliance Against
Family Abuse and the Salvation Army have zeroes by them because they did not
apply in the past year.Community Alliance Against Family Abuse has never
applied before and Salvation Army has applied in the past but not recently.
Commissioner West asked if that was St.George's Catholic Church that was
listed.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated i t is St.George's Catholic Community.
Commissioner West asked why they would need funds.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly commented it has to be a public program:i t
cannot be based on religion.They are requesting funds for rental assistance,
temporary housing,and medications.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 1 OF 17
Commissioner West asked if it is limited to members of the Catholic church.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they cannot do that.It is open to city
residents who qualify by virtue of proof-of residence.
Commissioner West commented they get the focus on their name.She asked how
i t falls under their auspices and how they monitor it.
Commissioner Brossman stated people go to them for help,and they,in turn,go
to the city for help.
Commissioner West commented that anyone could go to St.George's for help.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated that is correct.It is not church-
affiliated whatsoever.She watches closely for that.I t is not unusual for
one of the other agencies listed to refer clients to St.George's if it is
something they are not funded for and St.George's is,such as rental
assistance or utility payments.It must be based upon a proven need and they
must be a city resident.
Commissioner West asked how they prove they are city residents.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they can use driver's licenses,state
identification cards,utility bills and tax statements,but not a photocopy of
someone's business card.
Commissioner West commented a freeloader could not come in.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated the agencies a very good.Over the years
they have fine-tuned their skills.They have learned to work together so that
if they feel that someone is making this part of their normal life cycle,they
will alert the other agencies.They do cross checks to make sure i t is not a
habit.It is very rare that she has found the same names on any of these
listings.
Vice Chairperson Clabuesch arrived at this time.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated the requests for funding from the
applicants this year total $167,500.
Commissioner West asked why Reach Out gets what they want.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 2 OF 17
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated that is how the commission made the
recommendation last year.The recommendation is based upon the request,the
dollars available,and the need.
Commissioner West commented the Boys and Girls Club gets a lot of help out
there.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they get money from other agencies and get
donations.
Commissioner West commented they do a lot of fundraising.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated that is one of the requirements.When
they submit an application,they have to list who else they are getting money
from and who they have applied to.They could have applied elsewhere but have
not heard that they are getting funding.The commission starting asking
several years ago where else they are looking for money.The budget line item
for this funding is $80,000,which is slightly less than half of what has been
requested.There is a chance that if the commission gives a secondary
recommendation for an amount over the $80,000,such as $100,000,the council
may approve the higher amount.She does.not think the council will object to
the higher amount within reason.However,they would not approve $167,500.
She advised them they would receive a comparison table at the next meeting.
She asked if they wanted to go through applications.
Chairperson Payne stated they could and she could then explain what is in the
packet.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated the first applicant is Apache Junction
Reach Out Food Bank which is located across the street from the city complex.
It is on county property.Their primary function is to provide food baskets
or boxes to people who come in and request it.They will not turn anybody
down.If people come in asking for food,they will give them food.
Commissioner West asked if it mattered who that person was.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated it does not.However,the city funds can
only be used for city residents.They have other income in the form of
donations and funding from United Way,so they can use those dollars for
people who do not live in the city.Any money that this commission recommends
through the city has to be only for city residents.They have are very good at
recordkeeping.The amount of city residents they serve in a month far exceeds
any amount they have ever gotten from the city.She stated the top page of
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 3 OF 17
the packet is her checklist.The items listed are required by the city
ordinance,a copy of which has been included.She uses that to determine i f
they have given her all of the required information.The Food Bank is asking
for -a total of $20,000.It is identical to their request from last year,with
$15,000 going for the purchase of food and $5.000 for utility payment.They
had added a very large cooler so that they could keep additional food on the
property,and the cooler has to run night and day.They are very good on
reporting.They are always on time and are very thorough.She did not give
them the audit reports,just the things she thought they would like to look
at.She can provide the audits if they wish.The Food Bank is all volunteer.
There is no paid staff.John Snethen provided us with the contents of the
food boxes.She gets reports from them that state the number of people in the
family and the dollar value of the subsidy they received.It is a good
system.
Commissioner West asked if this food that comes from merchants is outdated.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated she did not think so.They get food from
St.Mary's Food Bank and they get a lot of donations from people.She donates
to them and so do average people.They get things donated from stores.
However,she does not necessarily think i t is outdated.
Commissioner West asked what about something like brick cheese.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they are able to tie into the program for
dairy products.That is one.of the reasons for the additional cooler.They
were given that opportunity'originally but they had no place to put it.She
added they also got $4,000 from Central Arizona Human Resources Agency to buy
meat.She stated the Boys and Girls Club of the East Valley had their
documentation in order again this year.There were a couple of times where the
local office was not late,but the Tempe office was.She now has the local
branch give her the report so that i t is on time.Their documentation is very
good.
Commissioner West commented they are asking for $37,500.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated that is correct.
Commissioner West commented they will only get $15,000.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated that will be up to this commission.They
got $15,000 this past year.This is again for an educational program like
last year.It is an after hours program.She goes past the facility a lot
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 4 OF 17
and i t is very busy.She advised them she had given them their list of
contributors,including some new ones.She assumes they are cash contributors
because they do have a lot of incoming local contributions.She commented the
next agency is Central Arizona Human Resources Agency.They are asking for
$10,000,the same as last year.They usually submit everything on time.A
couple of their reports were late this year.Her biggest concern is that they
did not expend all of the money;they returned over $4,700 at the very end.
They did not tell her until July 1.If they had known earlier,they could
have given the money to someone else.
Commissioner West asked what they do.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they do utility repairs or replacement of
things like refrigerators,heaters,evaporative coolers and air conditioners.
They also make properties accessible for people with disabilities.
Commissioner West commented one would think they would really use their money.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated Mary Lou Rosales,their executive
director,explained that they did not get the first check from the city until
October.They had already spent other money on people who had requested
things.She could have backed it out,but it occurred to her that she could
do that too late for it to be done.The balance of the money was returned.
The next applicant is Community Alliance Against Family Abuse.They are a new
applicant.
Commissioner West asked what they do.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they operate a safe house for victims of
domestic violence.
Commissioner West commented there is a lot of that out here.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly'stated there is a lot of it everywhere.They are
asking for $10,000 for an educational, program to prepare brochures and other
educational materials and literature.These are things they give out at
presentations.She does not know anything more about the program so they will
need to gather more information at the interview.
Commissioner Brossman asked who she should call to get more information on the
program.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 5 OF 17
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated she should call Christy Johnson at 982-
0205.She is most familiar with her.She is concerned with this use of
funds,as they have to provide her with very specific client service
information.They have to show who the.city:resident is that they are
serving.She does not -think it would fit if they are looking for city funds
to pay for copies of brochures.They cannot tell her who the city resident is
that they assisted.
Chairperson Payne stated that is one they would have to have come in and talk
to them.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated the next applicant is Mesa Senior
Services.They operate the current old senior center,soon to be the new
senior center.They are asking for $52.000;$22,000 is for congregate meals.
which are hot meals served at the senior center.They meet all the
nutritional requirements.She asked if the new facility will have a kitchen.
Deputy City Clerk Jan Mason stated i t has a full kitchen.They can make their
meals there.
Chairperson Payne commented they have meals on wheels,too.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they are asking for $15,000 for meals on
wheels.She knows from discussions from last year that they have •a waiting
list for both programs.It was a combination of not enough room at the senior
center and not enough money for the home -delivered meals.The third component
is transportation services.They bring people to and from the center,take
them to the grocery store,and take them to medical appointments.
Vice Chairperson Clabuesch asked if it would be appropriate for them to visit
some of these places to familiarize themselves with the programs.They could
go in,see what they are doing,and meet with them.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they would have to go through the open
meeting process if 3 or more of them go together.It would have to be posted
as a meeting.If only one or two go,it would not be a meeting.
Vice Chairperson Clabuesch commented they would be going for research.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated that would be an excellent idea.However,
they cannot go to the senior center today as i t is closed.She stated at the
top of the next page is the TRIAD program,which are new outreach services.
At the beginning of this year the police department transferred the TRIAD
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 6 OF 17
program over to Mesa Senior Services.Based upon what she could see,they had
an immediate expectation that this group would continue to fund it.She needs
to find out if these monies in the amount of $10,000 are some place else other
than the $80,000.She did not include i t in the $80,000 and she will let them
know at the next meeting.This is a former police program:she never assured
Dan Taylor that it would automatically be funded.
Commissioner West asked if this is for 9-1-1 cell phones.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated i t is.The cell phone program is where
they ask for donations of old cell phones,and somehow they are able to work
with the service providers so that they are programmed only to call 9-1-1.
Commissioner West stated they would be for people that are alone and in bad
health.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated that is correct.There have been no
problems with the documentation.She commented that this commission in their
recommendation to the city council last year made a notation that this group
may be needing.more money in this cycle.The people putting the budget
together for this budget cycle did not remember that.
Commissioner West asked if they go by the percentage of population.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they do not.It has been set at $80,000
for several years now.
Commissioner West commented it would be nice to know the specifics of Apache
Junction insofar as to how many are seniors,children,and others.
Vice Chairperson Clabuesch commented she did not know if they could do that.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they could probably get that information
in the next census which will be in 2006 or 2007.The commission had made
comments at the last budget cycle to the council that because of the new
center coming on line,there would probably be the need for additional
funding.
Commissioner West asked where the new facility is located.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated i t is across the wash from the city hall
complex.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 7 OF 17
Deputy City Clerk Jan Mason asked if she had seen the bigger building behind
this complex.
Commissioner West stated she had.
Deputy City Clerk Jan Mason commented that is the new multi -gen and senior
center.
Chairperson Payne asked if they are already in there.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they have not.Parks and Recreation has
moved in somewhat as they had to set up the program and equipment and get
staff used to doing what they have to do.The senior center has not moved
yet
Chairperson Payne commented if they wanted to see the senior center they would
have to go to the library.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated that is correct.They may be in there
until the parks people get situated and have that up and running.The next
applicant is St.George.They are asking for $20.000.Last year they
received $10,000.There were some things they did not give her,such as a
detailed expenditure statement and a source of funding from other governmental
agencies.She does not believe they receive anything from governmental
agencies.Some of the monies they got from United Way were included in their
financial statement.They threw a whole bunch of stuff together on their
financial statement.
Commissioner West asked if the city funds come from the state or the
governor's office.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they come from the general fund.The city
council determined years ago they would extract a certain amount of money each
year from the general fund to be set aside for this purpose.The city does
not apply to someone else for money it would in turn pass along.The general
fund is sales tax,income tax and different fees.
Commissioner West asked what year it was set up in.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated i t started in 1988.
Commissioner West commented they then have inflation.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 8 OF 17
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated i t used to be less,and then the council
put i t up to $80,000 a few years ago.
Commissioner West commented the population here has grown.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated she had no objection to the commission
making a recommendation,as they did before,that next year they would like to
have allocated no less than a certain amount.It would then be rolled in as
part of the budget cycle next year.St.George is asking for the money to
provide the same kinds of services as last year,which were rental assistance,
mortgage assistance,emergency medical,prescription drugs,utility
disconnection,and propane.Their recordkeeping has been very good;there
have been no problems.
Commissioner Brossman asked where the list is from last year of all the people
in the city that they helped.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they give quarterly reports to her.If
she wants a copy of that,she can give her a copy of each quarterly report.
Commissioner Brossman stated she would like that.
Chairperson Payne commented that the city does not fund for the first four
things they have listed on their report,which are salaries,medicare.office
and supplies.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated their contract is for hard costs.
Chairperson Payne stated i t is for paying utilities,rent,medical,dental.
prescriptions,toiletries and emergency travel.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly Stated last year's budget was projected at
$33,000,of which only $10,000 is from the city.They pick up the remainder
of the costs.
Chairperson Payne asked if their reports state how much they used for the
client.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated it gives her a name and address,the type
of identification,the nature of assistance,and the initials of the person
who processed the client.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 9 OF 17
Commissioner Brossman stated the bottom of their report shows that they put
away funds for a future project.She asked if she knew what that is.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated she did not.
Chairperson Payne commented she thinks i t is because of their current bank .
balance.It states 40 but 25 of it has to go some place else.That is what
i t looks like to her.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly suggested they ask them that at the interview.
She stated the last applicant is Salvation Army.They are asking for $18,000
and they are primarily for rental assistance.They did not meet the
requirements for submitting documentation.They are missing a lot of it.
They were supposed to send current records and they gave her things from 2002
and 2003.There has been some kind of transition at the Salvation Army
earlier this year where they moved some things out and closed other things
down.She has no way of knowing what is going on there.The last time they
applied there were some disturbing references by their auditors as to the way
they maintained or failed to maintain their books.None of that was in there
this time and she does not know if that is because they fixed the problem or
did not include it.The audit report came from headquarters this time instead
of locally.They did not provide most of the information that they needed to
provide.It appears they are not receiving funding from governmental or
nongovernmental agencies for this program.Any of their requests for other
funding has not been isolated for this program,and they need to know all of
what they are asking for all of their programs.She commented that is
basically it as far as the applicants go.
Vice Chairperson Clabuesch asked who it was that was allowed before.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they are polled up front for city
residency.She does not know the new captain.She does not know if they
really took a look at the requirements or if they are in the position of
making sure they are city residents.One of the problems she had when this
first started is that a lot of people have an Apache Junction address but i t
is not in the city.'It is out of the city;it may be in Pinal County some
place or in Maricopa County some place.She would have to cross those off and
tell them they would not refund.them the money.They are paid after the fact.
They submit the quarterly report and she then pays it out.It is the only way
she could make sure they were meeting their requirements.She noticed there
is nothing on their emergency assistance program that asks if they are a city
resident.It worries her that they are asking for social security numbers,
which she does not believe they.should be doing under the new federal laws.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 10 OF 17
It is up to the commission if they wish to interview them.It is her concern
that they have not met the criteria of the ordinance.
Commissioner West commented this is a lot of research,but there is no
conflict of interest or duplication.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated her concern with the Salvation Army is
that they would have to work very closely.with St.George's to make sure there
was no duplication.They do cross check on things like food,but they would
need to do so with temporary housihg.Also,if they are going to fund someone
for temporary housing,i t had better be within the city limits..They are not
going to pay for someone to move into Maricopa County.Also,if it is within
the city limits,i t needs to be a licensed business and they must be paying
city sales tax.
Commissioner West asked what the limitations are that are on temporary
housing.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated this is the first time they have had this
type of request.St.George's is very cautious.They will not give them 100%
of their rental payment.They will give them a portion of it with the
expectation that they will come up with the rest of it.The commission could
ask them to verify that when they meet with them,but her recollection is that
they want to see that match,and they want to see i t first before they give
the check to the landlord.She commented she will have copies of the
quarterly reports from St.George's for all of them at the next meeting.She
asked if there was any other information that they needed.She will find out
about the TRIAD program.
Commissioner West asked if they were free to go and research each one of these
applicants.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they can go to them,visit the facility
and talk to the people there.
Chairperson Payne commented she wants to interview Community Alliance Against
Family Abuse to find out what they want the money for.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated this is the first time they have been an
applicant.She thinks they have been a part of the Community Development
Block Grant process.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10.2005
PAGE 11 OF 17
Chairperson Payne asked if there were any other questions on the review.
There were none.She commented they would move to the next item on the agenda
which is the report on the 2004-05 funding recipients.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly commented she had already rolled that into what
they had just discussed.Her only concern was with Central Arizona Human
Resources Agency:-she would have liked them to have let her know sooner so
they could have sent the money over to the Food Bank because they always are
able to get out and stock pile food to have i t available.The notice was too
late for her to be able to do that.
Commissioner West asked why they did not watchdog on that.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they are usually very good.She gives
them a sample form and hopesthat they use it.Then she is able to just go
across and check them.
Commissioner West asked what she used to verify the city limits.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly commented she has worked here so long that she
knows the addresses by looking at them.It has become habit.
Chairperson Payne commented it could have helped the senior center,also.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly agreed.It could have been rolled into the meals
on wheels:there was almost $5,000 returned.
4.Discussion on interagency network program.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated for several years part of the money that
went to Superstition Mountain Mental Health,who did not apply this year,was
for them to do the interagency networking.It involved contacting the
agencies and having a monthly meeting.They informed her this year that they
are no longer going to do that.She was not sure what this group wanted to do
with it.The original intent was to provide that first push for the agencies
to start working together with the expectation that at some point in time the
city would step back and no longer provide the service once they were
established and had gotten to know each other.She spoke with a Pinal County
deputy attorney yesterday who is willing to take on the portion of sending out
the notices to the agencies of a monthly meeting.He has senior volunteers to
assist him.The Chamber of Commerce provides the room at no charge.People
bring their own lunches. so there is no cost there.It is only a matter of
sending out the monthly notices with the time and date of the meeting and
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 12 OF 17
arranging for the speakers.He feels that the agencies should be able to
volunteer to get a speaker on a monthly basis.There are about 12 members.
His only suggestion is that the city call a meeting and explain that
Superstition Mountain is no longer going to be providing the administrative
services and i t is time to send this in a new direction and that is the city's
recommendation.She told him she would run that by this group to see if there
were any concerns.
Chairperson Payne asked if they were expecting any funds for this.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated none of these groups came forward to pick
up the responsibility.The county is not expecting any funding for it:they
may already be receiving federal funds that will cover that.He has senior
volunteers that will run off the copies,stick them in the envelopes,address
them and mail them out.
Chairperson Payne stated she had no problems with it.She thought it was
great that i t is all volunteer and they are just going to do it.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated she will proceed with contacting Bob Brown
and working with him.They will set up a meeting of the various agencies and
let them know from this point forward that this is how it will be done.
5.Selection of future meeting dates.
Chairperson Payne asked if there was a certain amount of time for them to get
this all done.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated i t is up to them.The budget is already
approved.We are late this year because there were a lot of budget issues.
She did not know if there would be more than $80.000:she knew there would not
be less.They actually did not have more.She did not know if they wanted
another meeting to discuss the applications before they interview the people.
Commissioner West asked what is a fiscal year. '
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated i t is July 1 through June 30.
Commissioner West commented i t is not a lot of money.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly agreed.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 13 OF 17
Chairperson Payne commented they need to decide how many they are interviewing
first.They can then determine how many meetings they will need.She would
like to hear from Central Arizona Human Resources Agency,Community Action
Against Family Abuse and the Salvation Army.
Commissioner Brossman stated she would like all those and St.George's.
City Clerk.Kathleen Connelly stated she knows that Mesa Senior Services
director,Mr.Taylor,is real concerned about not getting $52,000.She does
not know if they want to meet with them.
Chairperson Payne commented they might want to meet with him to see what the
urgency is and why.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly commented she believed he jumped to some
conclusions and hired some people with the expectation that the funding would
follow.He was already told he should not have done that.
Commissioner West asked if Chairperson Payne would like to designate who she
would like her to talk to.
Chairperson Payne stated they -come to our meeting and we all ask them
questions.
Commissioner Brossman commented they have 5 out of 6 they want to interview
already when including the Boys and Girls Club.
Chairperson Payne asked if they wanted to hear from all six.
There was general discussion on who was interviewed last year and who they
should interview this year.
Commissioner West asked if all of them come in at the same time.
Commissioner Brossman stated they come in one at a time.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated this location will work out better.At
the other location they had to stand outside or sit in another part of the
room and listen to what you were talking about with the prior person.
Commissioner West asked if they were allowed to talk privately to each one.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 14 OF 17
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated i t is an open meeting.Under the open
meeting law,they can come in but they do not.They are very polite.It is
not like they want to -hear what the other group is doing.
Commissioner West asked if they see what the other agency is getting.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated this is all public record.Nothing is
secret.
Commissioner Brossman stated at the time of the meeting they do not know what
they are getting.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly agreed.
Commissioner Brossman stated they are just asking them questions.It is
afterward they decide.
Vice Chairperson Clabuesch agreed.
Commissioner West commented she worked at Boeing in engineering and when i t
came to salary they did nottell everything.You could not.
Chairperson Payne stated her schedule is now flexible now that she is retired.
She asked if they needed to have the meetings in the evening where it would
affect city staff schedules.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated she does not see any reason why they
should have to have a meeting in the evening.Any of these groups should be
available during the daytime hours.
There was general discussion on the dates available.Due to vacations and
surgeries scheduled for 2 members,it was decided to wait until September.
The consensus was to split the interviews into 2 meetings to be held on
September 7 and 8,with the recommendation decision to follow the final
interview of the second meeting,both Meetings to start at 3:00 p.m.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated she would do the interviews
alphabetically,with the first three being the Boys and Girls Club,Central
Arizona Human Resources Agency and Community Alliance Against Family Abuse.
On Thursday it would be Mesa Senior Services and St.George.She will send a
letter to the Salvation Army declining them;that could be done as part of the
recommendations later on.She asked if they wanted the agenda for September 8
set up so that as part of the agenda they could make their recommendations.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 15 OF 17
If they want to do it,it must be on the agenda according to the open meeting
law.They could do it that day,but they do not have to.
Commissioner West asked if all they do is say yea or nay for the vote.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated i t is a discussion on dividing up the
money and a vote.It could be 2 or 3 votes.
Commissioner West commented it would be hard to make an evaluation until after
they have the meetings.
Chairperson Payne stated they would interview the first three on the seventh,
make their notes,then they do the others the second night.They have then
completed interviewing the applicants.They can divide i t up after the last
interview since they are already here.
Commissioner West commented they could finalize i t at that time.
Chairperson Payne stated that is correct,if it is acceptable to all of them.
Vice Chairperson Clabuesch stated it was.They only have so much to work with
and there is only so much they can do.
Chairperson Payne called for a motion for the future meeting dates.
Commissioner West MOVED THAT THE FUTURE MEETING DATES BE SEPTEMBER 7 AND
SEPTEMBER 8 AT 3 P.M.
Commissioner Brossman SECONDED THE MOTION.
VOTE:Unanimous.
The motion carried.
6.Commission requests for future agenda items.
Chairperson Payne commented she wanted to make sure that the next agenda would
have that they would be making the final decision on September 8.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly asked if there was any other information they
would like from her other than the St.George's quarterly reports and for her
to find out about additional resources.
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 16 OF 17
Commissioner Brossman asked if they would be getting that information at the
next meeting.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated she could come in and get them sooner or
she could mail them.
Commission consensus was for them to be mailed out to them.
Chairperson Payne asked that they again be given the chart listing what they
had received in the past.It gives a history on how long they have been
relying on the city and how muth they have tried to do on their own.
City Clerk Kathleen Connelly stated they would have that at the next meeting.
One of the things the council and this commission have always said to these
agencies is do not -always plan on getting the money.The whole point behind
this program was for it. to be seed money to get them started and then wean
them off.Two cycles ago they started cutting back on Superstition Mountain
Mental Health until last year they were only given the funding for the
interagency service.This year they did not apply at all.This has been made
clear to all the agencies right from the start.
6.Adjournment.
Chairperson Payne adjourned the meeting at 3:55 p.m.
JoyAVPaylfe
ttr,
Kathleen Connelly
Ch6fterson City Clerk
HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION MEETING
AUGUST 10,2005
PAGE 17 OF 17